Where it started
Plenty of readers, nothing of its own to sell them
An audience that arrives from somebody else's feed is rented. The rent goes up whenever the platform feels like it.
The traffic was never the problem. Six social platforms were sending readers, from around 48,000 people at the top down to 18,000 at the bottom, with direct visits behind them. For a site that had never bought a click, that is a real audience.
What it lacked was anything to do with them. The site pointed readers at a white-label dating platform that paid a commission in pennies and gave us no control over the experience, the branding or the reporting. There was no email list worth the name, no product, and no reason for a reader to come back on a particular day.
Search was the other gap. A site with hundreds of articles and a domain dating back to 2022 was picking up almost nothing from Google, because the content had been written for social feeds and nobody had ever laid it out in a way a search engine could follow.